News

It was the breathtaking WFH compo win that stunned Australia – and now the lawyer responsible issues a message that will alarm every boss

The lawyer who represented a council employee who won a worker’s compensation claim after tripping over a puppy fence has defended the judgement, claiming it is ‘uncontroversial’.

Lauren Vercoe, an asset programmer for Adelaide’s City of Charles Sturt Council, was working from home on September 19, 2022 when she tripped over a 60cm puppy fence, breaking her arm and hurting her knee in the fall.

Her initial claim for compensation against Local Government Association Workers Compensation Scheme was rejected in October 2022.

But in a judgment handed down by the South Australian Employment Tribunal on 18 October, Ms Vercoe’s injury was found to have arisen from her employment.

Auxiliary Deputy President Magistrate Jodie Carrel found the fall occurred during an ‘authorised coffee break at her place of employment’.

The decision, reported by this publication on Tuesday, prompted a wave of incredulity as readers questioned its logic.

‘That’s outrageous when her employer has no health and safety controls over her workplace at home,’ wrote one.

‘They are not responsible for hazards she erected, which wouldn’t have been allowed in her city office.’

But now the lawyer who represented Ms Vercoe has defended the judgement, explaining that it is a ‘no fault system’ for workers compensation claims – and all that they needed to prove was that the injury had been sustained while at work.

Donald Blairs, from personal injury firm Wearing & Blairs, said he was ‘surprised that people are surprised’.

‘People have been lodging workers’ compensation claims for events that happen in their workplaces, which may well include places outside of the usual office, since forever, and this is just a continuation of that,’ Mr Blairs told Daily Mail Australia.

‘If she was a TV repairman in someone’s house who had tripped over a dog fence or something similar, there’d be no controversy. It’s pretty straightforward and no one would dispute that.

‘The only thing that was unique about this case is I suppose she was in her own house as opposed to a different house.’

He added: ‘It’s a no fault system. The legal test here is that it was an injury that occurred in the course of her employment.

‘And getting up to get a cup of coffee is something that’s deemed to be in the course of your employment on a day-to-day basis.’

Mr Blairs said he had seen similar cases and the only difference in this one was that the council decided to fight it.

‘I’ve had other similar cases where people have tripped over their coffee table or the ledge of their front door whilst putting out the washing and they’ve all been accepted,’ he said.

‘This is not unusual. The only thing that is unusual is the council decided to run it as a bit of a test case and came unstuck.’

Asked why the council may have taken the claim to trial, Mr Blairs said: ‘I don’t think it was dollars and cents. I think it was that they wanted to set a precedent.’

City of Charles Sturt Council declined to comment.

Ms Vercoe had put up a 60cm metal pet fence across the doorway to her sun room, which she used as a home office.

The fence was erected to keep a colleague’s puppy, who she was dog-sitting, away from her pet rabbit.

On the day of the incident, Ms Vercoe started work at about 8.30am and rose to make a coffee around an hour later.

But, as she stepped over the fence, one of her feet caught it, causing her to lose balance.

She tried to break her fall but failed and landed with her full weight on her right knee and her right side, experiencing ‘instant and extreme pain’.

Her husband rang an ambulance and she was taken to Royal Adelaide Hospital where she was treated for a fractured arm, a suspected dislocated shoulder and a painful right knee before being discharged later that day.

The SA Employment Tribunal judgment agreed with Ms Vercoe’s submission that she ‘fell during the course of a paid break’ and that her ‘injuries arose out of or in the course of her employment’.

‘Ms Vercoe submitted that it was not to the point whether the council had provided the pet fence, known about the pet fence, or told Ms Vercoe to erect the pet fence,’ the judgment noted.

‘Simply, there is nothing that limits the application of the workers compensation scheme by reason of an injury occurring due to a feature of the workplace not known or authorised by an employer. ‘

In her evidence, Ms Vercoe also shared screenshots of a council video about flexible working arrangements which encouraged employees to ‘take regular breaks, ‘get out in the sunshine’ and ‘enjoy time with the dog’.

Magistrate Carrel also criticised the legal firm who initially rejected Ms Vercoe’s compensation claim for suggesting ‘she exaggerated her evidence when convenient’.

‘Rather, Ms Vercoe is a worker who has done her best to get on with things after suffering a significant injury,’ Magistrate Carrel noted.

Ms Vercoe returned to work after six weeks.

The amount of compensation she is owed will be decided at a later date.

It’s understood the compensation claim was only to cover a couple of medical bills and the few weeks Ms Vercoe was not working.

Ms Vercoe declined to comment.

Related Posts

Pauline Hanson appears on the verge of tears as she fires back at a male critic who told her to ‘toughen up – you can dish it out but you can’t take it’

Pauline Hanson has hit back at a male critic who told her to ‘toughen up’ – as she surpasses $500,000 in donations for a legal appeal over her ‘p*** off back to Pakistan’ comment. Earlier this month the One Nation leader lost a defamation case brought by Greens Senator Mehreen Faruqi. A judge found she had racially vilified Ms Faruqi when she told her to ‘p*** off back to Pakistan’ in a tweet.

Trump nominates Matt Gaetz to be Attorney General in stunning move

President-elect Donald Trump named controversial Florida Congressman Matt Gaetz as his nominee for Attorney General in a move that is bound to outrage Democrats and even shock many Republicans in Washington. Gaetz is a MAGA firebrand who has taken aim at both GOP House members and Democrats alike as he has remained a close ally of Trump. While Trump appears to be valuing staunch loyalty as a prerequisite for his choices to key posts over standard qualifications, the choice of Gaetz as the top law enforcement official in the land left many scratching their heads – if not scraping their jaws off the floor.

Mum who ‘stabbed her three children to death’ is found dead after massive manhunt over triple murder that shocked France

A MUM who allegedly stabbed her three children to death before fleeing in the French Alps has been found dead in Switzerland. French cops launched a massive manhunt after Deborah Pel, 45, fled the small town of Taninges leaving a note behind. The bodies of the two boys aged two and 11, and a 13-year-old girl were found at the family home near the Swiss border on Tuesday.

Karine Jean-Pierre is asked if Biden and Harris were ‘awkward’ at first lunch since the election – and the reaction says it all

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre was asked Tuesday if President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris’ post-election lunch at the White House was ‘awkward.’ Harris returned to the White House complex Tuesday for the first time since her bruising election loss a week ago to former President Donald Trump. Aides stood on the Eisenhower Executive Office Building’s steps to catch a glimpse of the now former Democratic nominee, who told them to keep the faith before she walked over for her lunch with Biden.

Rachel Reeves to unveil ‘big bang’ on British economy with biggest pension reform in decades which could unlock up to £80 billion worth of investment

Rachel Reeves will today unveil a major pensions shake-up designed to unlock up to £80 billion of investment in British infrastructure and business. In her Mansion House speech tonight, the Chancellor will confirm she is pressing ahead with plans to merge pension schemes to create new ‘megafunds’ capable of investing in major infrastructure projects and emerging industries. Ms Reeves will argue that the move could unlock a wave of private sector investment that will boost her anaemic growth forecasts and ultimately provide better returns for pensioners.

Ed Miliband hopes to establish ‘common ground’ with Donald Trump on climate change – after US president-elect repeatedly referred to the issue as a ‘hoax

Energy Secretary Ed Miliband has spoke of his hope to establish ‘common ground’ with Donald Trump on the climate issue. The US president-elect has repeatedly referred to climate change as a ‘hoax’ and has also vowed to pull the US out of the Paris Agreement, which commits it to cutting greenhouse emissions as part of the effort to curb global warming. Speaking about the move towards clean energy, Mr Miliband said: ‘What I think is so striking about what’s happening – whether you talk to businesses or talk to other countries – people are getting on with the transition.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *